wait wait wait...WTF?!?!?!?!?! so it was all a dream? anwser please
sesshomaruhoney88- Thu 20 Dec 2007
I am sorry, but i will not accept that ending. it was extremely well done and it works. BUT I hate the fact that you seem to have this vendetta towards Inuyasha. What is it with you liking to torture the poor guy?
Also. I would like to say that I did in fact love your fic and read it start to finish in only two days. I will also save it to my memory (in my head not my comp) and reread it at some point later on.
for the sake of my sanity when that day comes the last few paragraphs i will take as Inuyasha was having a nightmare and then waking up to the reality of his son. for it would be much to cruel otherwise.
Rumiko would be scandalized that you did a much more reality based version of her own works, Congrats
sasha- Tue 04 Dec 2007
I dont care what anyone says, that ending was absolutely beautiful.
Maybe this sound a bit dark, but i thuoght it was a sweet ending. Anyone whos ever been in that state of depression thats so deep will be able to agree with me that; when your that far gone, the only thing that feels real anymore IS the fantasy. When your 'awake' is depressing. Reality is the true nighmare, In your sleep, and your fantasies is where you truly live. Atleast he was able to make his fantasy so tangable he could dive in it and live 'happily ever after' ....
Congrats to the author, truly you are amazing. I usually check this site for updates on storys I like every week or so; with this it was nearly every day. To get me that hooked I deffinetly a feat, and the only other author who's bben able to do that is elle6778. I had to read a few of her storys before I was totally hooked, yet on your first try you've hypnotized me, wow.
Thank you, and I hope that we may have the honor of reading another one of your storys soon.
-sasha
gina- Mon 03 Dec 2007
well i must tell you. i truly loved reading this story!!! well done. i look forward to reading more from you,
and if you ever go on to become published. please you must let me know so that i may continue to read your work. thank you so much for sharing what beautiful gift you have been given. in the mean time i can't wait for a new story =-) take care!
swasdiva- Mon 03 Dec 2007
Good God. It's Donnie Darko all over again. Talk about Psychologically f-ed up ending. I'm literally staring at my computer screen with no idea how to respond. I can't say I'm upset with the ending, as it's got a heaping helping of emotional gravitas and the concept is absolutely stunning - in more ways than one - but it does pain me that Inuyasha can't get a break. Interestingly enough, he's imagining people who are definitely real, who he's never met, unless you're insinuating that the entire canon story of Kagome falling through the well is also Inuyasha's imagination. That makes me sadder than I've ever felt before...my beloved cat, Hamwich Gamgee the Camper (I know...how the hell do I get off questioning your naming practices??) could keel over right now and I wouldn't be as traumatized as I am about this ending. Still, for creativity's sake, it's very well done, very conceptual and beyond the point of being original, especially in the IY fandom. Still, a girl can't help but hope...
This is the most depressed I've ever felt after reading a fic, but again, I can't say I wasn't impressed.
And referring back to Donnie Darko, you need to listen to the song "Mad World" as redone by Gary Jules specifically for that movie. It's the summary of this story.
rowdysgirl- Mon 03 Dec 2007
oh, you are bad on just so many levels i can't even begin to count them!!!!
However, you made a very good point that a sweet, happily-ever-after ending wouldn't work as well as the bitter ending you chose. and this is still a classic...don't put down toilet paper or kleenex either, how do you feel when the roll is empty and you're needing some? both are extremely important forms of paper and, in my not-at-all humble opinion, are sure signs of how civilized our society is. that and flush johns.
but now you owe us a sequel. it doesn't have to be long, but now we need you to bring a pretty girl out the damned well so the story can begin!!!! or perhaps we should all just realize that this story occurred before the manga and anime. yes, that's how to deal with it. humans love they happy endings.
it's still a good job and you have a right to feel proud of yourself!
Lena- Sun 02 Dec 2007
WOW...I have never seen someone put such a twist on a story in my life. That was a great story, that is the type of story that can be read so many times. Keep up the freat work and I cannot wait for your next story.
Demonlordlover- Sun 02 Dec 2007
I read the first chapter and knew if I wanted to retain my sanity I'd have to wait until this was finished to read through.
Fantastic story. The angst was entirely believable. Sometimes I dislike angst simply for the reason that it seems forced. When it plays out in a realistic manner, I'm an instant fan.
The characterizations were wonderfully filled out so that their motivations were never in question.
Abi, as a character, was a great addtion and I loved that you paired her with Inuyasha. The relationship between Kagome and Sesshoumaru was well-done and even better was the healing between Inuyasha and his Taiyoukai brother.
All in all, a wonderful story, and I thank you for sharing it with us!
Crazar- Sun 02 Dec 2007
OMG! I never saw it coming....lol....but I absolutely loved it! Thanks for that twist...I like it better than fluff.
Aiesha- Sun 02 Dec 2007
Well.... yeah that's pretty much all I can say. I liked your story until the epilogue. I kind of wish I had skipped that part. Don't get me wrong. This was very well written with a lovely mix of angst, humor and action. I just think you laid it on entirely too thick there at the end. They could have not led fluffy, happy ever after lives, without it all being a fantasy. That hurt my heart love. Otherwise, Excellent story!
TONI- Sun 02 Dec 2007
I REALLY DIDN'T UNDERSTOOD THE LAST PARAGRAPHS
luna- Sun 02 Dec 2007
oook the end allmost had me screamin oh f###ing NO!
first ending that had me worried.
wow, i must say congrats on such a wonderfull fanfinc. you should consider having a celebration party you acomplished something many wouild wish to do in their writing. so from one writer to another i give you my praise and good luck in your next fanfic
Jean- Sun 02 Dec 2007
At first I thought OMG. After the initial shock, I think you are correct. This story had many dark aspects, such as Rin constantly throwing herself off of high places to end her re-existence. A happy ending perhaps would have seemed nonsequitur in a story filled with one terrible thing happening after another. I thoroughly enjoyed the read and I congratulate you on the successful completion of your dark tale.
snowbird- Sun 02 Dec 2007
Well I'm sorry to say I have to agree with those that are disappointed with the ending. For me it took away the enjoyment of the story. I'm sorry to be so negative, but I could have cried. For my part, I plan to back up and ignore what's wrote after he falls asleep. Sometime in the future, I plan on reading it again because it is a good story, but will stop at where they fall asleep. The rest will not exist.
Ok, first of all I love the story but whilst I was reading the epilouge all I could say was "Oh God" ... repeatedly.
That was the most tragic thing that anyone has ever thought of, and I tip my hat to you for it.
You moved me to call on the Lord, and honey, believe you me that is a feat. Congratulations on a great run.
Biteswhenprovoked- Sun 02 Dec 2007
I love the story but the ending is sooo sad. I didnt see it coming
As much as I love happy endings, I think you're right when you said that it just wouldn't work with this fic; it would completely throw it off course. So in essance, I really enjoyed this story and I can't wait to see what you come up with next!
I am in awe of you right now. I loved this story from start to finish, and the ending of this story is like nothing I've ever read on here; sure we've all seen the happily ever after, the no it didn’t work out, and we've even seen the dream ending; but that was so different and so deep. Your ending was absolutely perfect.
There Is Is Indeed!!!! I TOTALLY Agree w. U!! I LOVED That Epiloge! U Did the Right Thing!!!! I Really Liked How InuYasha Woke Up and DID Have That Life!! He Just Thought He Didn't! Totally Bril!!!! When U Start Another Story I'll B There 2 Read It!! Thanks 4 My Time Well Spent!
Luv,
Kagome-Chan ♪
I just reread some of my favorite chapters and the end. I guess it my version of fanfic-self-flagellation. I am really moved. The ending just makes sense (despite the fact it is traumatizing me). I'm really impressed.
I can barely see the computer screen I'm crying so hard. Part of me wants to say "How could you?" But I totally understand. And yet...oh shit I'm so conflicted. Curse you! But it was so beautifully written and poignant. I just loved this whole fic (even/especially the end). I'm sad to see it end. But the way it ended. I'm floored.
gina- Fri 30 Nov 2007
that was one of the most beautiful chapters i have ever read. i cna'f decide what was more beautiful, the birth or the uncle nephew time. well done =)
luna- Thu 29 Nov 2007
awww that little talk between the baby and inuyasha was just so intense and wow, actually the whole chapter was intence especially the whole birth it just seemed so intimate and everything you would expect out of a birth between two people in love.
swasdiva- Tue 27 Nov 2007
Oh my God, I have a crit.
Please tell me you did not name their child "Puppy". He won't need to be hanyou to get his butt kicked on the playground with a name like that. Man, I know I'm being harsh, but that's like naming your kid "Baby"...
*swasdiva's imagination is suddenly wearing black leather and dancing like Patrick Swayze* "Nobody puts Puppy in a corner..."
Alright, I take it back. It's pop culture gold. Katsu can even yell that in a fight! Koinu will no doubt grow up to be gorgeous, and he would definitely be like the wind through some lucky bitch's trees (sorry, Dirty Dancing reference). And now that I look at it, there are phonetic similarities to Kohaku...
Speaking of Katsu, what does Katsu mean, anyway??
Alright, all extremely evil crits aside (I'm being very mean today, what's wrong with me?) this chapter was the DEFINITION of ASTOUNDING. It seriously was publish-worthy. I have never been so in love with Sesshoumaru as I am with him in this story. I've watched him mature from a youkai boy to a man, and more of a man than his up-on-a-pedestal father ever was. How fondness over the memory of a blanket can do that to me, I have no idea, but it was so tender, and so *wise*, that I can't help but feel a pang in my heart. Of course, Sesshoumaru would never, especially at you point you've placed him in his life, ascribe to being wise, but isn't that what makes a man wise in the first place, his humility? Who would've ever thought you could associate Sesshoumaru and humility so easily. You've done it. That scene made his character more tangible than I've ever encountered. Kagome was amazingly written, too, but her insight and tenderness is somewhat taken for granted, I guess. All in all, the way you've let them grow together is nothing short of transcendental. Certain questionable naming practices aside (maybe it's a family name? I got stuck with one of those...), this is a satisfying end to en extremely emotional journey.
Sweet_Dark_Silence- Mon 26 Nov 2007
Awe, how cute!
rowdysgirl- Mon 26 Nov 2007
i am so sad this is almost over, this is such a good story! when you load the epilogue i am going to sit down and read the whole thing from start to finish. then i will read it over again... i honestly believe that you have created a classic in fan fiction. my one wish is that you could publish it. i would pay money to read your work! i will keep my eyes open for your next venture.
I think you did a very good job on this chapter. The story as a whole was amazing, I can't wait to read the epilogue, I'm sure it'll be great as well! Great job!
Kagome-Chan- Sun 25 Nov 2007
GR8 Chapter!!!! That Was Amazing!! Can't Wait 4 the Epiloge!
i guess even i cant always get what i want. (sniff..sniff..lol) all good stories must end i guess. i think this will be one of those stories i will read again and again.
tilayha
Excellent chapter! Very sentimental and sweet.
Well done...*many hugs and many smiles*
Jean- Sun 25 Nov 2007
You did a great job describing the intimacy between Sesshoumaru and Kagome as Sesshoumaru revealed some of his childhood memories. Giving birth can make you shed your modesty and inhibitions rapidly. It makes sense that during such a private time Sesshoumaru would be able to shed his most troubling secrets to share with his wife. In the end, they become so much closer. The pup's name, it means "puppy" doesn't it? If so, that doesn't sound very demon-fearsome. Perhaps that was just a term of endearment.
snowbird- Sun 25 Nov 2007
I liked the birthing scene. It was touching and intense. It seems Sesshoumaru was finally able to make peace with his childhood. I like the bond they have. They know their love for each other without having to say the words. Like the old saying "actions speak louder than words". Can't forget Inuyasha. He was absolutely hilarious with Kagome. I laughed so hard, I almost choked. Also, it was a very touching scene him bonding with his new nephew.
BeautifulDeception09- Sun 25 Nov 2007
Oh No I Could Never Stop Reading This Story I'm Addicted!
U Wanna Make Sleepy-time With Ur Neighbor Thats Too Cute And Kinda Lustful At The Same Tyme!!
Awww Kagomes Baby Sounds Soo Cute!!
No No No No! Don't Send Sun And Abi To OC Heaven We'll Miss Them Too Dearly!!!
Love The New Chapter Update Soon!!!
piratequeen- Sat 24 Nov 2007
What a brilliantly written chapter! I love the way you sandwiched the meat of the story with the damn-funny/preciously-sweet Inuyasha parts. Your work is amazing. Please include at the end of next chapter some hints for dealing with Atonement Withdrawl.
What An AMAZING Chapter!!!! I LOVE How Rin and Sun R Coming Along!! I'm Sad It's Only 2 More Chapters! Do U Think You'll Start Another Story When This 1 Is Done? Cuz If U Do, I'll Read That 1 2!!!! Please Update As Soon As U Can!!
Luv,
Kagome-Chan ♪
I FINALLY CAUGHT UP ON MI READING OF THIS STORI! Okay So I Laughed The Whole Entire Time When Sun Met Sesshomaru And I Think It's Soo Cute That Rin Has Her A Mate! The Battle Scene Was Awesome And All Around I Must Say This Is Close To Being Mi Absolute Favorite Story!
marufan- Thu 22 Nov 2007
this is a very beautiful story!!! i love it! please update soon! and note me when you do!
snowbird- Thu 22 Nov 2007
Oh Inuyasha I love you. You are such a funny, sweet jerk. I really had a good laugh at him being made the chief polital advisor. Won't be too many arguments from the council members with him around. Yes, I agree. We could do with him being unloaded on Washington DC. You talk about cleaning house! It was so sad and sweet the talk between Sesshoumaru and Sun about Rin's mortality. It's too bad she couldn't take on his lifespan when they mated, but I guess that means a person can't get everything they wish for. He will just have to be strong and enjoy her while he can. I'm glad that Sesshoumaru finally feels happy with his life. I regretfully have to agree with the ending of this beautiful story. As far as I know, all questions have been answered and problems solved.
Jean- Wed 21 Nov 2007
Sesshoumaru is so clueless about pregnant women--stretch marks, the marks of pregnancy, the final pressure on the belly button. That scene was quite amusing, as he was thinking that he should keep his mouth shut. I liked the way you dealt with Rin's mortality. Sesshoumaru's advice was very wise.
gina- Wed 21 Nov 2007
nope i don't like it at all I LOVE IT!!!!
this chapter was even better. the longer you tell it the better it gets..
well done and i await more happily
=)
Another great chapter; I'm so happy that they are all back together. I think you handled Rin's mortality issue very well, and it was such a Sesshoumaru thing to say! I can't believe the fic is almost at an end :( It is awesome and you are doing a wonderful job; I can't wait to read more!
Also, I agree with you with the fluffiness. I think when Sesshoumaru acts as Rin's father it is totally cute!
faye- Wed 21 Nov 2007
Good chapter. I've been thinking about death a lot lately (we will all face death), and reincarnation (it's something I believe in as a Buddhist). But with youkai, I'm not sure since they are considered "immortal" they do seem to age (like totosai) so I would guess they aren't totally immortal like gods, but they just live and very very long time. Well anyways, I've truly loved reading this story and I'm excited for the end. I hope you will continue to write for us in the future!
I am sad to see this one coming to an end. you are right in the fact that it has come together very well. I have been captivated since the first chapter. I do hope you do go through with the one shots. it would be fun to see what they are all up to and see how suns family reacts to his mating with rin. tilayha
swasdiva- Wed 21 Nov 2007
Alright, for a completely nonsequitor intro, I fell over howling at the hiliarity of your comment to snowbird. Actually, what's more funny, or perhaps tragic, is that I would hands-down vote Inuyasha into the presidency over any of the dingbats currently running. Alas, you have to be born here in the US, and Inuyasha's Japanese...not to mention two-dimensional...sigh... (though you would never guess that with the way you write his personality)
Another amazing chapter, and I most appreciate, again (geez I feel like a broken record sometimes!), the realism you always manage to capture in moments where most people go off the deep end of melodrama. I'm speaking of the Pregnancy Conversation. It was so true to life that I could imagine actually having that talk with someone in the sanctity of our bedroom, in the tiny moments when the most important things are spoken in whispers. It was very stirring and honestly, the fact that Sesshoumaru is starting to embrace his inequities and share them with Kagome makes me love him more. You've realistically made him into a man who would have that talk with Sun, and it doesn't seem unabashedly OOC. His progression to that point of understanding was very natural and heartwarming. Huh...never thought I'd associate Seshoumaru with heartwarming, but there you have it.
Speaking of Sun, I adore his and Rin's interaction, even the underlying sadness and maturity. I guess, the beauty of it is that he's taking his moments with her for all they're worth, even in the face of inevitability. That's a good, good, good boy, and I love you for giving Rin someone like him. Squee!! =^^=
I'm gonna cry a big fat tear when this fic is over. I mean it, the proverbial fanfic "Single Tear" will trail down my cheek, in extreme slow-motion, even. That's a feat. I feel like there's something else I wanted to gush about concerning this chapter, but for the life of me I can't remember what it was...OH YEAH! I appreciate how you worked in aspects of that pregnancy article you read (that's what I'm assuming) and you pointed out the physical manifestations of being pregnant, AND made Sesshoumaru marvel at them. Ah, the wabi-sabi of it all...the beauty of imperfection. That's what I wanted to tell you, yeah...Good stuff!!
And BTW, I'm glad you enjoy my biblically long reviews. ^^ I've never been known for being succinct, especially when I'm enamoured with something.
piratequeen- Wed 21 Nov 2007
So fucking fabulous! This chapter really moved me. I actually had a home birth and am very excited to read when it is Kagome's turn. I'm sure you will make it beautiful. I can tell already I'm going to cry my eyes out.
Rinseternalsoul- Wed 21 Nov 2007
I had mixed feelings about this story in the beginning. I first began the adventure with showers of tears for a lost taiyoukai with a broken heart. Things began to brighten for Sesshomaru when Kagome entered his life and then Inuyasha was ripped from him bringing many more tears. The theme has a darkness that has left me almost hesitant to read on, wary of more heartbreak for them all. Even Rin's bleak outlook on the world left me feeling sad and despairing for the bright loving girl that had experienced so much pain in her life. The amazing thing about your story, though, is the unexpected happiness just around the corner. Each tragedy has somehow been transformed into a triumph. Rin and Inuyasha were brought back through bursts of imagination that left me breathless. The little glimpses of joy made it all worth it. Small bits of well placed humor and happy occasions kept pulling me to the next chapter. It really has been an emotional ride. Bringing Sun in to guide Rin back to the world of the living was incredible. I love him! He's a wonderful character. You have done an outstanding job bringing this story together, and I very much look forward to the remaining chapters. Thanks for the read!
Rin
chevonne- Wed 21 Nov 2007
I really like this story a lot. and i was wondering how long you going to give Kagome and Rin to live. sense Rin had died
on more than once and Kagome is a miko/.
will their life span be longer because of who they are mated to. Not even Sesshomaru will live forever.
This has been one of the best reads for me in a long time
chevonne- Wed 21 Nov 2007
I really like this story a lot. and i was wondering how long you going to give Kagome and Rin to live. sense Rin had died
on more than once and Kagome is a miko/.
will their life span be longer because of who they are mated to. Not even Sesshomaru will live forever.
This has been one of the best reads for me in a long time
piratequeen- Mon 19 Nov 2007
Another fabulous chapter! Can't wait to read more.
swasdiva- Mon 19 Nov 2007
God bless Inuyasha. I mean, seriously, could he have entered that council meeting in any better fashion? That would be a Hell No. Who needs diplomacy when you have a presence like that. I absolutely loved that scene!
This entire chapter, and the one before that I somehow missed (urk!), were amazing, as always. You still have this enlightening knack of making this story about inner feelings, even in the midst of battle. during Sesshoumaru's fight with Hoshi my focus was on Sesshoumaru's conviction. The same holds true for Sun's brave declaration (that poor, poor, poor boy)...again Sesshoumaru's reflections stole the scene. I don't know how you make such sweeping settings intimate, but you do it everytime, and it lends this story a credence that's lost in many epic SK fanfics. No matter the gravity of the scene, I feel like I'm engaging on a private moment, and sharing in the growth of these characters.
Sun is one of my favorite OC's ever. His personality is similar, though not identical, to what I image Kohaku would've been had he had a chance to live a somewhat normal life. Sun's gentleness, combined with his raw power, makes for a very interesting and accessible character. Go Rin!!!
I'm very eager to see how you wrap this story up, even as I'll bemoan my loss of such timely updates (seriously, woman, how the hell do you write such great stuff so damned fast!?!? *_*). I'm especially glad that most of it will be devoted to SK moments, even though I really, really want to see Katsu in action. With those two as parents, I can't even imagine that kid's personality. @_@
Absolutely amazing work! You're stuck with me till the end!
Great chapter! I felt so nervous for Sun :) Sesshoumaru is so cute acting as a dad, as reluctant as he may want to act as such. Keep up the great work!
rowdysgirl- Mon 19 Nov 2007
i'm still laughing...yeah, poor ol' sesshy, can't kill that young whippersnapper without hurting rin! but, oh, it would be such a good feeling for him to be able to do so!
wonderful chapter. i loved every word.
Jean- Sun 18 Nov 2007
Thank goodness the cat is out of the bag before Rin came home. I really like Sun, and Sesshoumaru didn't kill him. So all is right with the world. I loved Inuyasha's diplomatic speech with the Inu Council. Ha!
snowbird- Sun 18 Nov 2007
I'm glad Sun told Sesshoumaru before the women returned. It gave them more bonding time, once Sesshoumaru got over being angry. I just loved Inuyasha's "diplomatic" approach to the council. Politicians are the same everywhere. Now, I'm on pins and needles for the couples to reunite.
YAY!!!! I'm So0o0 Glad Sun Had the Courage 2 Tell Sesshomaru!! And I Am Likewise Glad Sesshomaru Didn't Kill Him 4 It! (Laugh) Will There B a Part 4 2 This Story? Or Is Chapter 25 Really the End? Anyway, Please Update Soon!!!!
Luv,
Kagome-Chan ♪
Bahirah- Sun 18 Nov 2007
Yay Houshi is dead!! I love how you did the "lets take back what's ours" segment and solved the "I have a suicidal chick for a daughter" thing. Really well done and well thought out. Dude I'm jealous!! I wish the concepts behind my papers were as good as yours!
Oh and tell your editors, that they're awesome as well!
More! More! More! Are you planning on working on anything else?
gina- Sun 18 Nov 2007
i'm sorry im late in reviwing.. but this chapter was great. poor sun.. but it seems like she will be happy.. i can't wait for more!!! =)
Faye- Sun 18 Nov 2007
Great chapter again! Great job with the interations between Sun and Sesshoumaru. I can't wait to see what happens when everyone is together again!
Suicide- Fri 16 Nov 2007
Wow. What progress, especially with Rin. Goodness, everyone is having kids!
"I can teach you to kill stuff" --- funny.
gina- Thu 15 Nov 2007
i cna see it as i read the growth .
what it is i think i like so much is that it's messy,.. you know real like life. some times it just is and you hope when it's all said and done taht you can smile and see the sun. and chap21 is fantastic!!!!! =)
snowbird- Thu 15 Nov 2007
I am so glad you invented Sun. He is so precious! And funny. I'm so glad you put him with Sesshoumaru and Inuyasha. I'm glad Rin is finally getting herself straightened out mentally.
TONI- Thu 15 Nov 2007
OH I AM SO DIGGING THIS FANFIC! UPDATE SOOON POR FAVOR
faye- Wed 14 Nov 2007
This chapter really felt like I was watching it play out, like it was an actual anime. It was simply delightful.
Jean- Wed 14 Nov 2007
I love the way you wove the Inu pack's travels and adventures into your story. Hoshi's search for allies was quite amusing, discovering they were all favorably impressed with either Sesshoumaru, Inuyasha, and/or the Miko. The brothers' search for allies was funny too, as they didn't think they would necessarily find any. As for Rin, something drastic was needed to make her want to live again. The drive to mate and reproduce is there for a reason. Perhaps Sesshoumaru will be happy that Rin has an interest in life again, after he gets over the anger and shock of the facts behind her reason. Great chapters.
I really love how this story is progressing. You are keeping the characters in character while doing a lot of out of character things. I don't think I would be able to pull that off very well! Keep up the great work, I can't wait to read more!
NO NO NO NO!!!! No Disapointment Here!! I'm So Happy It's Kohaku! That Made Me Laugh SO Hard!!!! (Out of Happiness, Mind You) What An Unbelievable Twist. U Get the BEST Ideas!! PLEASE Update As Soon As U Can!
Luv,
Kagome-Chan ♪
Katie33h- Mon 12 Nov 2007
You: Dude ... why are you reviewing this chapter twice?
Me: Shrugs ... because i read it twice and i just wanted you to know how much i enjoyed it. Is that wierd and like 'Cable Guy-ish' ...
Meara- Mon 12 Nov 2007
Nice chapter; well written and told delicately considering the main subject. It has never ceased to amaze me who otherwise rational, intellegent people can lose all vestage of sense once their hormones kick in. Rin is no different from any other girl her age even 500 years later. The consequences aren't thought of until it's too late.
Rin has become a very edgy character in this story. You take the time to show her pain and the desperate measures she seems willing to go to in order to make it stop, even just for a little while. I fear for her, which only shows that you've managed to make her a thee dimensional, believable person in an otherwise fantastic setting.
Very nice indeed!
Meara
sessholuva03- Mon 12 Nov 2007
pleaze add on! I love ur story!
rowdysgirl- Mon 12 Nov 2007
i will give you this, with this story, you are improving the length of time i can hold my breath. i find myself doing so for long periods of time, so engrossed in the action i become, that suddenly my body inhales and i realize that minutes have gone by since the last inhalation.
i find your twisty, twiney, turny imagination absolutely fascinating; even when i predict the next action and am correct, you manage to make it new, clean and sharp. like you're telling me: 'yes, you got it, but it isn't quite how you thought it would be - look again!' there is so much sweetness in your tale, but it isn't sweet. the characters take so many bitter actions, but it isn't bitter. you display their pain, anger, anguish; their joy, laughter, then sorrow; they are real people, 3-dimentional, emotional, irrational; and i hope none of them move into the condo next door to me... i couldn't deal with the drama.
it is interesting to see how you've dealt with the various self-destructive behaviors of your characters. i have seen some similar behaviors in people i knew. i am impressed with how well you've resolved so many of their issues. i look forward to the next chapter.
i was recently given a good piece of advice....don't second guess yourself. there is a story in your soul that screams to be told. tell it, get it out. this story holds true to what i know of japanese history, heck in most of the world at that time girls were sold as early as age 6 to procure land and power. even today females are used as barganing tools, sold into sex rings and such. your dipliction of rin and sun was just wonderful. no pain, no assumptions, just a raw need for two people to forget thier troubles and just feel. well done!!!
tilayha
Katie33h- Mon 12 Nov 2007
Ho ho ho ho ho Rin tsk tsk tsk ... I really did love this chapter. I feel like Rin, as well as Kohaku, would have some serious issues when they grow up. I am sure that dying and in kohakus case killing a ton of poeple could have serious effects on ones sanity.This was scadelicious! i love it.
swasdiva- Mon 12 Nov 2007
I KNEW IT!!!!
Um...yeah...
Again, I'm daydreaming about your story and going through the possible scenarios of who Kagome's child would be. I went through the whole Touga thing (waaaay too cliché and blatant), the Ryukossei thing (hey, he did kill people and is connected to the Inu fam) and all the others you had Kagome pick through. Then, BAM. There he was, smiling in my mind, a Kohaku with white hair. Great choice, I think. Interesting, because his soul and Rin's already shared a deep connection, and it's very poignant that they could form a familial bond. Rin as Kohaku's big sister...wow. They've both seen the other side of death (even if, being reincarnated, he doesn't remember) and I'm sure the connection will again be intrinsic and solid. It'll be interested to see his personality in this life.
I think the Rin scene was well done, and I'm not really squicked at all. You gave very valid points as to why Rin wanted it to happen, and frankly, yeah she's a tad younger than when I did anything adolescently stupid, but I also never died several times over. I like this Sun kid, too. For some reason he reminds me of the soft-spoken main character kid in Super Bad (ever seen that movie?). Cute, clumsy, lonely, afraid, but able to make good decisions when he needs to (in the future maybe).
I loved the part with Inuyasha and Sesshoumaru, too. While I expected Kouga's appearance (but not a little red-haired Kouga-spawn!! Squee!! So cute!) I appreciated the Akitoki cameo and the mention of the bats and other characters we've seen throughout the series. The brothers' introspection was well-written, too. I adore how you've shaped them into true brothers.
All in all, it was another great chapter. I can't wait to see how Sun reacts to Sesshoumaru and vice versa (that poor, poor, stupid boy!!). Of course, with Sesshoumaru's line of thought concerning a hanyou's place in the world, perhaps he wouldn't completely oppose Sun and Rin together (aside from the fact that they're both so young). And just thinking of Sesshoumaru as a mentor of sorts...*shudder*...oh Sun, you have no idea what you're in for, do you?
Better take a pack of that Opium...
Still lovin' your story. Just let me know when it comes out on DVD. ;)
Love this story! You've written Rin so well--please just don't make her a drug addict.
Your fic is extremely interesting and addictive. Keep up the great work!
heerako- Mon 12 Nov 2007
I love this story soooooooo much. I really liked this chapter. Yeah, it's a little bothersome that Rin is so young, but the way you write it and her reasons make it seem like it needed to happen. But please continue! It brings a smile to my day!
gina- Sun 11 Nov 2007
omg!!! what an amazing story! i couldn't stop reading i'm sorry i didn't reveiw as i went, but i couldn't stop reading. wow, what a gift. and i can't wait for more. well done and brava!!!! ( because you are a girl =) )
snowbird- Sun 11 Nov 2007
I bow to your wisdom and respect how you handled a touchy subject. You detailed more of Rin's background than any other author. I can understand how she was wise beyond her years. You are right about girls becoming women much earlier in their life than todays females. I was thinking with the mind of a modern female. You'll have to forgive me. I'm 57 and should know better since my own mother was married and pregnant with me at the age of 14. I sometimes forget that she was once a child-woman. I agree that sometimes young people searching for something that's missing in their life will make foolish decisions. I think we're all guilty of that sometime in our life. Also, I think this was the beginning of a healing for Rin's soul. So again I bow to your wisdom and it was tastefully done. Also, I'm glad you've decided to keep him in the story and am excited that their mated. Abi is a blessing in disguise for her understanding and helpfulness. I'm so glad Sess and Inu are finding out how well liked and respected they are and collecting all kinds of allies. Yippeeee! I eagerly await the next updatel.
I'm sitting on the edge of my seat.
snowbird- Sat 10 Nov 2007
I am so glad the brothers are finally---brothers! Hopefully they'll soon realize just how much they're truly respected and even liked. And have allies coming from all directions. Because of this, I don't want to see a lengthy war. Sess and Kag need some peaceful, happy time together. I felt so sorry for Sess and his last night with Kag. They don't need to be apart for very long. I hope I caught it correctly that Kag is having a son. Usually re-incarnations are many years apart for Inuyasha stories so it could be someone she knows of and not necessarily met. Maybe Touga? Someone that powerful did not go through life without his fair share of innocent deaths. Oh and wow! Inuyasha's son is the heir! I guess because his mate had the first male pup? I'm glad he's with Abi. He needed her stabilizing force. And Rin! She really does have mental issues. I hope this mystery boy helps her come to grips with her problems and NOT SEXUALLY. She's only 12. I don't think you would write such a thing anyway. Hopefully, she and Kag can become close again as she slowly moves into womanhood. Oh dear me, it seems I'm writing a book so I'd best shut up and wait for your next update.
Byjinder- Sat 10 Nov 2007
With every chapter this story get better and better. Thank-you for writing it. It's so beautiful.
I have fallen in love with this story. I just hope Rin eventually recovers. Ja ne, IDK
toni- Sat 10 Nov 2007
r u gonna make Kagome's child a killer?
Katie33h- Fri 09 Nov 2007
omg... i almost died laughing at that last line. That was too funny.
Jean- Fri 09 Nov 2007
I guess Rin is not recovered after all and Kagome is being neglected by Sesshoumaru. However, I gather that Rin will be going with Kagome, Abi and Katsu to China, while Inuyasha and Sesshoumaru try to take back the West. This sounds like they are living under the Chinese (?) curse: may you live in interesting times.
Taje- Fri 09 Nov 2007
Wow, poor Rin! will girlfriend ever be right? A rough time for Kagome and Sesshomaru. Right, so many things can get out of control in a rocky relationship. Strength is needed. I am happy for Inuyasha and Abi. This is really wonderful, I am so enjoying your story and your imagination. Peace!
swasdiva- Fri 09 Nov 2007
"Like Who? I don't know anybody."
....
BWUAHAHAHAH!!!!!!!
Sorry...*tear! snort!* I just...oh, irony, how I've missed you. Such a short line, and it carries so much power: hilarity, poignancy, revelation. I can't wait for the next chapter, just to see Inuyasha's reaction. I for one wouldn't know how to feel. I mean, centuries of your life are peeled away to reveal an acceptance you'd never thought would come. It's...baffling, for lack of a better word. I really can't wait to see it.
Other than that, yet another great chapter. The Rin twist was good and completely unexpected, well, not so much that she's still struggling with depression, but rather who she met. I'd just like to repeat that he was practicing the Wind-Scar WITH HIS CLAWS...
WTF?? Other than that, I'm glad she has a chance to examine the essence of her fears and sadness. There's a Resmiranda fic entitled "Wolf Like We" (wow, shameless plug and it's not even my fic...) with a similar take on how she deals with her fear of wolves (along with another well-known IY character...*cough*). If you can't beat it...well....uh....fuck it. So to speak. Of course, that's not quite what I'm expecting here. The root of the situation allows a very tangible means of her to face her fears, whether through romantic potential with this boy or just getting to know him, having a physical outlet for everything quaking inside. I welcome any opportunity for Rin to be at peace.
And yeah, I figured it *would* be silly to let such heavy concepts dangle in the wind with a convenient little epilogue. I was thinking more along the lines of what characters you were specifically focusing on and if, since Sesshoumaru and Inuyasha had come to some sort of understanding, your story was over. I'm particularly glad you're continuing and covering such a broad range of leery topics. Again, as I always stress with your writing, it makes it that much more real.
Wow. I think this is my longest review ever. *_* Apparently I need a hobby...something other than fanfic reading! -_-*
Oh No!!!! I Wonder Who the Incarnation Is!! And InuYasha Is So Silly! 'I Don't Know Anybody' HA!!!! I Laughed Really Hard At That!! Please Update As Soon As U Can!
Luv,
Kagome-Chan ♪
Constitutiona- Fri 09 Nov 2007
i have to say, the last line in chapter 19 is my favorite so far. but then, he's always that dense.
BeautifulDeception09- Thu 08 Nov 2007
Lovely Chapter ... It Almost Made Me Cry When They Attacked Kagome I Thought The Baby Or Kagome Was Going To Get Hurt ... Ummm I Can't Wait To Read More Update Soon!!!
Gr8 Chapter!!!! I Feel So Bad 4 All of Them Tho!! Abi 4 Her Sacrafice, InuYasha 2 B Seperated From His Pup When It's Only 2 Days Old, Sesshomaru 4 All the Pressure, Rin 4 Her Depression, and Kagome 4 Her Pregnancy and How Bad She Feels 4 Sesshomaru All the Time. Poor Poor Situation! But Only a Gr8 Writer Such As U Could Make It That Way and Believable!!!! Please Update As Soon As U Can!! Thanks!
Luv,
Kagome-Chan ♪
swasdiva- Wed 07 Nov 2007
Would this count as Season 2 or Season 3? I swear to you I feel like I'm watching prime time TV. I didn't think you'd continue into another complicated story arch, but I guess it's to be expected considering they're stil playing Swiss Family Robinson and the West is crumbling. Though I guess "playing" is not the opportune word, here, is it? Again, I am utterly amazed and impressed that you manage to root this story in such realism. You have this deep understanding that fairytale elements do not a compelling story make. Even in an otherworldly setting such as this, the emotion and motivations are painfully real. I think that's the major reason why your story has become so popular, because your readers can relate to the characters' feelings. (Okay, so I've never exactly taken back a kingdom that was owed to me, but hey, I've had some big presentations at work...yeah...) And I present you the Fanfiction Medal of Brave Writing for not backing down on Rin's pain and having everything turn up sunshine and roses when Sesshoumaru officially adopts her. Considering what she's been through, major depression is a given. Kudos on exploring that issue and not backing away to rush the Deux Ex Machina happy ending.
I must say, though, that even though I have a healthy appreciation for the angst, I do hope there is some sort of hopeful resolution for all involved. And I want to see Katsu and future SK baby speak!!! (That is, if it fits into the story, natch. T_T)
So yes, one heinously long review later, you've churned out another amazing chapter.
Sesshy's koi- Tue 06 Nov 2007
Thank was a great chapter and I can't wait for you to update.
Faye- Mon 05 Nov 2007
yay! That was GREAT! I totally did not expect to see Touga! I'm glad the brothers were able to work together and revive InuYasha. I can't wait to read the next part of the story, we need some comic relief and maybe some romantic relief as well (in the form of some Sess/Kag maybe ^_^). I'm glad you're having just as much as fun writing as we do reading... the difference is you know that is going to happen next! (for the most part) Great work.
swasdiva- Mon 05 Nov 2007
I could not have imagined a better resolution. You didn't *just* have Inuyasha lumber his stubborn way out of hell, nor did you *only* have Sesshoumaru forge his stubborn way into hell (notice Sesshoumaru does not "lumber"). Neither was the quintessential Hero, the proverbial Savior. They worked *together* and reached for each other blindly, working only on the barest of senses and the most ardent faith that the other was there. In all honesty, have we ever seen a more striking example of how much alike these two are? Neither sat by and *let* Inuyasha's death happen, and in the end their tenacity (since that's a little more positive than stubborness) literally pulled them both to safety. The moment Inuyasha was through the barrier and all they could do was stare at each other, a million sentiments echoing in silence, I swear to you I lost it. These were tears of joy, though. It was simply too much of a beautiful scene for me to keep my praise inside. I must admit, though, that I was counting on a Touga cameo, and you didn't disappoint. When I really get into a story, I tend to spend countless hours slacking off...er, I mean... imagining what future chapters will be like. So Touga was in my daydreams, and I was glad to see he made it into reality. Even though I know you have another chapter to go (I'm guessing an epilogue of sorts?) this resolution was pitch perfect. I adore this story and will definitely look for your future work.
ty- Sun 04 Nov 2007
i love the story, the plot and the characters are amazing
but just a question where's kagome??
you discussed rin, shessy, inuyasha, abi, their father, shessy's mom, but where's kogome?
That Was An Awesome Chapter ... Inuyasha Is Back! Touga Is Proud! Everything Is Wonderful ... Update Soon!!!
April- Sun 04 Nov 2007
I was just wondering about your statement about Kagome and Sesshoumaru having children that weren't ugly. Jeneji's mother said that his father was the most beautiful man she had ever seen and on the show he was't ugly. How does that play into your story? Or is that excuse just for Kagome's benefit.
Suicide- Sun 04 Nov 2007
This fic has become one of my all-time favorites. Personally, these psychological and deep stories are so much more interesting than the normal fics I come across on this site. I love the way you delve into their pasts and traumas. There so much character development so the reader comes to sympathize and understand their thoughts. I'm truly amazed how deeply you explored theses characters and how they came to me. More so, I loved seeing these characters mature and overcome themselves and the challenges they faced. I cannot wait for more.
Hannah- Sun 04 Nov 2007
Hey, just wanted to say that I thought the seventeenth chapter of Atonement was fantastic. It was well written and touching, but I do have one question....where was Kagome?
jen- Sun 04 Nov 2007
this is so awesome possum!
Katie33h- Sun 04 Nov 2007
woah woah woah ... wait just one minute... what happened between him and Kagome is everything alright? when he left to get Inuyasha they werent really on the best of terms ... are things ok now? sigh> this is a really great story and i have throughly enjoyed it.
Angelisa collins- Sun 04 Nov 2007
I think you should make Kagome feel unneeded. Like inuyasha has been home for three weeks and Kagome is left out. Sessoumaru (the male she loves) Is playing catch up with rin and the same with inuyasha and his woman.
One day she just runs away and about one weeklater Rin ask where her mother to be is. It sends Every one in to a questioning state then panic at relization.
Kagome mean while Has been starving, Is cold, And is really sick.
They All Find HER and CRY abuot her health.
TONI- Sun 04 Nov 2007
SO KAWAII!
YAY! Another Segmant of the Saga Finished!!!! I Only Say Yay b.c Another 1 Is Coming!! (Laugh) I'm So Exited! ^_^ PLEASE Update As Soon As U Can!!!!
Luv,
Kagome-Chan ♪
Sweet_Dark_Silence- Sat 03 Nov 2007
*perks up with the development*
Yay! Yasha's back!
*flips over backwards in chair from over enthusiasm*
Ow! *rubs head*
That's the sixth time this week!
*voice drips with self-disgust*
Can't wait for the next installment!
Jean- Sat 03 Nov 2007
The father was /is quite the jerk. As much as Inuyasha is not my favorite character, I have to say he showed great inner strength in this chapter. I'm also glad that Sesshoumaru was able to accomplish what he did to assist in bringing Inuyasha back from the dead. Although I still feel that Kagome is being relied upon to just be there for Sesshoumaru, even after he was so horrid to her, it appears he is just sitting with Rin for hours and has not even seen Kagome. But he did say that he could not stand to look at her. I wonder how long that will last. Will he be going home to Kagome or just have a life being Rin's father?
I Would Understand If I Were Kagome 2!!!! He Lost His Brother!! And It Was HIS Fault! How Would ANY1 Act?!?! I Feel So Bad 4 Them All!!!! I Keep Having 2 Tell Myself Its Just a Story!! (Laugh) Please Update As Soon As U Can!
Luv,
Kagome-Chan ♪
swasdiva- Fri 02 Nov 2007
And another thing...I'm really impressed and mollified that you didn't immediately jump into a HEA solution just to appease your readers' weak stomach for fictional realism.
Super shock twist with potentially tragic consequences = 1 chapter
Uber painful angst due to tragic timing = 1 chapter
Leaving an impression that could damn near last a lifetime = priceless
swasdiva- Fri 02 Nov 2007
OHHHH MMYYYYY GOOOODDDDDDD!!!!!
I thought it couldn't GET any worse than the last chapter, but I was...
*SOB!*
WWWRRRROONNNGGGGGG!!!!!!
*WAIL!*
In all seriousness, you could not have feasibly written a better response to the last chapter. Their anguish was tangible in every word, and extremely realistic. Such a tragic death is the most difficult universal shift a single being can endure, and crippled under the weight of such regret, how else is Sesshoumaru going to respond, especially considering who he is? This chapter...was just...profound. That's it, profound. It was jarring and naked and raw, but the hope aluded to in the next chapter...well, I'm fallng into the fog, so to speak, but dammit if I'm not crying out for a second chance...
I freaking LOVE this story.
So sad yet so good! I really love the dark turns your story has taken. Your writing makes up for the disappointments and you have a way of twisting the narrative in a way that satisfies the reader yet doesn't compromise the story.
And poor Rin! Of all the characters, she's the most passive - she's been dead for most of this story - yet she's one of the most changed.
Sweet_Dark_Silence- Fri 02 Nov 2007
*eyes streaming*
NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNooooooooooooo!
Why did Yasha have to die!?!?!?!
*bawls hysterically*
NNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!
That wsa so sad! You are doing a great job, keep it up!
snowbird- Fri 02 Nov 2007
Another tearjerking chapter. Now I have a snuffy nose from crying too much. I understand fully from where Sess's pain is coming from. I just hope his mother doesn't make a heartwenching demand in exchange for bringing back Inuyasha.
faye- Fri 02 Nov 2007
wow!! will she do it?
you can really FEEL how these characters are just being torn apart. Each one is devastated by the same yet different reasons. If Nikkou brings InuYasha back, I think we've reached the "ressurection" limit for the story, lol, but thats not for me to say!! sorry, lol. Please update soon
rowdysgirl- Fri 02 Nov 2007
don't worry about the size of your chapters, not when every word you write is intrinsic to the story. i'm not saying you haven't made mistakes in the technical side of writing, but i will have to read this story many more times to be able to find them because every time i read it i get caught up in the characters' lives and forget everything else. that means: you're good.
Cochrann- Thu 01 Nov 2007
wow...that took some guts portraying sesshoumaru and rin like that and I applaud every bit of it. Very realistic portrayal of grief and ramafications of a ill lead life.
Jean- Thu 01 Nov 2007
Very moving. Yet I feel for Kagome who always seems to get the raw end of every emotional deal.
snowbird- Wed 31 Oct 2007
NOW HOLD ON A MINUTE! You have to bring back Inuyasha some how. It's just beginning to get good between him and Sess. He,s going to be a father and he's supposed to help Sess regain the Western lands. That's a large part of the story right there. Plus, now that Rin's back (unless she's a fake for some reason), Sess and Kag need to give her a baby bro or sis. That would be kind of comical. The brothers having 2 pregnant females to contend with and their mood swings and cravings. (HINT,HINT) Oh well, I can only dream. I anxiously await to see what your imagination brings forth.
Dh7- Wed 31 Oct 2007
OMG you killed inu and abi was preggers T_T... But Will sess be able to bring him back by asking his mother?
OH NO!!!! NO NO NO NO!! InuYasha Can't Die! (Crys) That's So Sad!!!! PLEASE Update As Soon As U Can!!
faye- Tue 30 Oct 2007
That is so sad it moved me to tears! please update soon!!
Nichole- Tue 30 Oct 2007
| ack! no no! you cant kill inuyasha!! save him with tensaga!!
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |